Investors today have more investment options than were available to the average investor just a few decades ago. While having multiple options is usually a good thing, too many options can cause system overload and lead many people to avoid making decisions.
Investing is a broad topic that often seems intimidating to people who are new to investing. And that is understandable – there are dozens of investment vehicles, hundreds of investing strategies, and thousands of investment options.
Before we let analysis paralysis get the best of us, let’s take a look at investment options for the first time investor.
DIY Investing or hire a financial planner? This article is primarily aimed at someone who plans on starting their own investment plan. However, these steps can easily be done with the help of a financial planner.
If you are beginning your journey into investing, you want to choose a financial planner that will walk you through these steps and be able to easily explain why each investment option is good for reaching your goals, and direct you to additional information so you can better understand how and where your money is being invested.
Easy Places for Beginners to Start Investing Today
If you want to start investing today, without putting your investments in high-risk positions, these investment accounts will make it easy for you to get going while you get your investing legs underneath you.
Betterment is one of the top robo-advisers in the United States and makes investing easy by doing all the picking of investments for you. I detail more about robo advisors below, but it basically works that you answer easy questions and those questions determine how much risk you can tolerate.
I like Betterment because they really make the process simple and have a great record of investing.
Real estate investing has long been a great method for building wealth. However, the vast majority of individual investors have felt unable to capitalize on this market due to high barriers to entry.
Fundrise, a robo-real-estate-investor of sorts, is seeking to solve this problem. Fundrise promotes itself as a hands-off, low-cost investment platform that seeks out real-estate investment opportunities to acquire and improve for its investors (i.e. without a ton of cash to throw around).
Fundrise reports 8.7-12.4% historical annual returns and a “low-fee approach” (which translates to 1% annually on your assets).
I’ve discussed M1 Finance elsewhere, but it bears reiterating here.
M1 Finance is a robo-advisor, but they have diversified themselves in several ways from the “traditional” robo-advisor through qualities such as greater personalization of investment, no fees, and the ability to purchase stocks and ETF’s.
These features (and many others) make M1 Finance a viable option for investing beginners.
Peer to peer lending has become a great alternative investment for people looking to get a solid rate of return, but want to avoid the stock market. Instead of investing directly in a company you can lend small business owners and individual money through platforms like Lending Club.
The average rate of return runs between 5% and 7% depending on how much risk you take. The good news is you get ratings on every loan and you can invest in any loan for as little as $25. This means with a $250 investment in LendingClub you can diversify into ten different loans.
Exchange Traded Funds
ETFs are a great way for a beginner to get into the stock market, have a little more control than with Betterment, and still not have to pick stocks for themselves.
What an ETF does is allow you to buy into mutual funds at much smaller amounts than a mutual fund company will allow you to purchase.
For example, when I started investing in mutual funds from Vanguard the smallest amount you could invest in one of the mainstream funds was $3,000. With an ETF you can buy a small share of the mutual fund just like you buy a small share of a company when you purchase a stock.
For ETF investing I really like TD Ameritrade because they allow you to invest in more than 100 ETFs without being charged any commission. This is a great way to get started into the ETF market without paying any extra fees.
Defining Investment Goals
The first thing we want to do is look at our investing goals. This will help us determine what type of investment vehicle is best for our investment. Before we go much further, let’s define saving and investing; normally saving is a short term engagement and investing is a longer-term engagement.
Saving goals often include major purchases such as a car, down payment for a home, college tuition, major vacation, etc. Many traditional “investments” would be inappropriate for savings because they may lose value. Most savings should be kept in low volatile accounts such as a high yield savings account at an online bank or in a CD. Here is a list of high online bank interest rates that you may find helpful.
Common investment goals include longer-term goals such as retirement, keeping pace with inflation, college tuition, and other longer-term goals. You will notice that I listed college tuition under both saving and investing. Which group you place each of these under depends on your time frame. You can probably take on a little more risk for an intermediate length investment. For example, my daughter is 8 months old, so I can take a little more risk with college fund money right now than I could if she were 16 years old.
Find an Investment Vehicle
After determining your investment goals we need to find an investment vehicle that meets our needs. No, I’m not talking about buying a pristine 1953 Buick from the Barrett-Jackson Auction company. I’m talking about something more fun and exciting – things like IRAs, 401ks plans, college saving funds, brokerage accounts, and more.
There are many specific investing plans that have tax breaks or other incentives that make them worthwhile to use. For example, IRAs and 401k plans are tax-advantaged retirement plans that give users tax breaks either now or in their retirement years. 529 College Savings Plans and Coverdell ESAs offer tax advantages for college savings. These tax advantages can add up to tens of thousands of dollars in the long run. So take advantage of them!
Open an Investment Account
Once you determine your investment goals and which investment vehicle you will use, you should open an investment account. This could be as simple as enrolling in a 401k at work (often done automatically), or starting an IRA, which takes about 15 minutes. Other options include opening a brokerage account.
Opening an investment account is often as simple as providing your information, signing a form, and transferring funds into your account. But knowing the type of investment will help you narrow down the best place to open your investment account.
Stocks, Bonds, and Mutual Funds, Oh My! The Options are Endless!
Again, I will point to the concept of analysis paralysis and the importance of having investing goals. Before becoming overwhelmed by the sheer number of options, take a hard look at your investment goals and eliminate anything that won’t help you meet your goals. You should be able to eliminate a large portion of the available options just by checking them against your investment goals.
Most beginning investors should focus on low-cost, easy to manage investments. And the investment that best fits this description is the index fund.
Index Funds – The Best Investment for a First-Time Investor
Most people should simply try to have their investments match the markets. Over the last 100 years or so, stocks have returned close to 10% each year, on average. Of course, there are ups and downs. Some years the returns will be great, and in other years, the losses will hurt.
But we can’t time the markets. No one can. Not even the professionals.
So the best course of action, for most people, is to put your money in the markets and try to match them as efficiently and as cost-effectively as possible. The way to do this is with index funds.
Index funds are designed to match a market segment or index, such as the S&P 500, for example.
The benefits of index fund investing are many: low investment costs, tax efficiency, strong diversification, and they are low-maintenance.
Exchange Traded Funds
Exchange Traded Funds are similar to index funds, but they are traded on the open market like a stock. They sometimes have lower fees overall, but usually come attached with brokerage or transaction fees. The benefit for investing with ETF’s is usually a cheaper set of ongoing costs. ETF’s are also usually better for large lump sum investing vs. dollar cost averaging because of the brokerage fees.
Avoid Buying Individual Stocks and Bonds as a Beginning Investor
Many first-time investors think they need to know how to buy and sell individual stocks and bonds to be able to make money in the markets. While it’s true you can win big, you can also lose big!
When you are beginning to invest, the better thing to do is to let the markets do the heavy lifting for you. You can do this very easily by investing in index funds that are designed to follow the market.
Over time, matching the market will grow your investment portfolio more reliably than most people can do by buying and selling individual stocks and bonds (and this includes the “professional” investors and money managers!).
Mutual Funds – Experts Try to Beat the Market (and Most Fail!)
Be wary of managed mutual funds. Mutual funds are a collection of stocks and/or bonds that are managed by a management team with the goal of earning greater returns than the general markets. Many mutual funds feature certain asset classes (small growth, large growth, commodities, etc.), or from various investment sectors (financial, health care, industrial, technology, etc.). You can have stock mutual funds, bond funds, or a combination.
This sounds good in principle, and some managed mutual funds perform well. However, most managed funds simply cannot consistently beat the market over the long term. On top of that, they generally have higher management fees and are less tax-efficient than index funds or index fund based ETFs. Those added costs are another hurdle to beating the market.
For investing, I prefer efficiency. And that means minimizing fees and other costs. The best way I know how to do that is to match the market by investing in index funds. Index funds are dirt cheap to run and generally have the lowest fees possible.
Target Date Funds Remove the Guesswork
If you are a first-time investor, you are probably doing well to get this far (defining your investment goals, finding the appropriate investment vehicle, and opening a Roth IRA).
If you are still overwhelmed with your investment options you may find it best to invest in a target date fund, which automatically diversifies your portfolio to a weighted asset allocation based on your target retirement date.
Or, to put it more simply, a target date fund is a mixture of stocks, bonds, and other investments that is designed to have more risk while you are young, then gradually transfer your funds to less volatile investments as you get closer to your target retirement date. The management is done automatically; all you do is invest and let the fund manager do the work.
Target date funds have some disadvantages, however. They are often less flexible than an asset portfolio you create yourself and may come with higher expense ratios than a do-it-yourself plan. I am not advocating target date funds as the best plan for everyone. But I will say that they are a great place to get started if you simply don’t know where else to start.
The idea is to get in the habit of investing and get your money in the game – particularly in accounts that have investment limits per year (401k plans, IRAs, etc.). Get started, get in the habit, then move your investments to a more appropriate investment one you have a better idea of how you can accomplish your investment goals on your own.
Robo Advisors Make Investing Easy
Many new investors don’t feel comfortable investing, often due to their lack of understanding of how the markets work, or how they should best allocate their investments. This is understandable. There is a software-based investment solution called a robo advisor that can help investors take the first step.
Robo Advisors work like this: you choose your risk tolerance and the software recommends a mixed percentage of stocks and bonds based on your risk tolerance. Once you make an investment, they automatically change your asset allocation based on your settings. In some ways, it’s very similar to a target date fund.
Betterment – a Great Investment Tool for Beginning Investors
One such Robo Advisor is Betterment, which is an easy to use investment tool that will automatically allocate your investments based on your desired risk tolerance. Betterment is the top robo-advisor brokerage in the country. With Betterment, all you have to do is set up an account, set your goals, and determine your risk preference, after that, their tool will handle the rest.
Betterment offers a variety of features including:
- Easy-to-use, even for beginning investors
- Automatic investing
- Tiered fee system
- Read Betterment Review
- Open a Betterment account
At this point, you have it all – the goal, the investment vehicle, an open account, and an idea of what you want to invest in. The next step is to get started. If you are just beginning your investments it’s probably not a good idea to try and time the market.
Dollar cost averaging through automatic contributions is a great way to get started because it will help smooth your investment returns over the long run. You can often set up an allotment from your paycheck for 401k contributions and sometimes investment contributions to brokerage firms or other investments.
Automating your contributions will make it easier to stay on track, just be sure to be aware of any contribution limits that may affect your investment planning (retirement accounts such as 401k plans and IRAs have annual contribution limits).
You don’t want to contribute too much money to your accounts! If you find that you have additional money to invest, it’s best to open a brokerage account for your additional investments.
Monitor and Adapt Your Investing Strategies
Ahh, you thought we were done, didn’t you? Not quite.
Investing and saving are two different things. It’s easy to set up a savings account or CD Ladder and leave them alone until the term is up. But investing requires a more hands-on approach. I’m not advocating day trading, but you do need to be aware of how your money is allocated and how your investments are performing.
It’s a good idea to track your investments with money tracking software tools so you can see it all in one place, and it is good to perform periodic spot checks and adjust your asset allocation as necessary. My favorite software program for investors is Personal Capital, a free online investment tool.
Some people prefer to do this on an annual or semi-annual basis, or any time they have a major life event that changes their investment goals. (Maintenance is one of the reasons I recommend a target date fund for beginners; it removes one step from the equation until they can learn more about asset allocation and other investment vehicles).
Does anyone have any other helpful advice for the beginning investor?