I Bought a New Car, and Why it Was a Good Idea For Me

by Ryan Guina

new carMost people recommend not to buy a new car because they depreciate so quickly. And we all know you shouldn’t put a lot of money into a depreciating asset – especially one that most people won’t keep long enough to pay off. Well, I went against that advice, and bought a new car in November of 2005. There were several reasons I bought a new car, but I will tell the story and the reasons will unfold.

The first reason was – I needed a different vehicle. The truck I owned at the time was a manual transmission, and I was scheduled to have back to back knee surgeries (one on each knee). I lived alone at the time, so I needed a reliable means of transportation that wouldn’t cause me pain to drive. I needed a car with an automatic transmission. Oh, and I lived in a location where having a car is a necessity due to the complete absence of public transportation.

Lack of local options. I lived in a fairly small, military town in west TX. There are several recurring themes in military towns – one of which is the propensity for auto dealerships to charge much more than they would in other towns. The other thing I had going against me, was small town dealerships often charge more than dealerships in large cities. It only made sense for me to go to a larger city to buy my car.

So I traveled. Thankfully, my parents lived in Houston, a large city with plenty of dealerships fighting for sales. One weekend I made the 6.5 hour drive to visit them and shop for another car. I had done plenty of research and determined I wanted a late model used car, and I had several models in mind. But there was a problem. A big problem.

A natural disaster. November 2005 was shortly after Hurricane Katrina, and almost all of the used cars in the Houston region were bought up by hurricane refugees who relocated to Houston after the gulf region was devastated. The remaining used cars were almost as expensive as new cars, and damaged cars were just starting to “flood” the market. There was a substantial amount of automobile fraud around this time period. Based on the price I would have had to spend to buy a used car, and the added risk of buying damaged goods, it was actually better for me to buy a new car.

I did my research, and narrowed down my choices to a few selections, then test drove them. In the end, I purchased a brand new car that was relatively inexpensive, economical, sporty, and is fun to drive (it has a Tiptronic style automatic transmission with a manual shifter). I also got a full warranty, and a guarantee that the car had not been subjected to the ravages of flood waters. In that post-Katrina environment, that was a very big deal.

I made the deal, not the dealership. I will write a more detailed article about this later, but basically, I went into the dealership and told them the deal I wanted, how much I would pay, what I wanted for my trade-in, and gave them the option of accepting or not. To be honest, the deal was good for all parties.

For my situation at the time, buying new was the best choice for me. If I were in the same situation again, I would make the same decision. Now though, there is no premium on used cars and there aren’t as many flood damaged cars on the market, so my decision would probably be different. But I do not regret my decision. I have had this car for 2 years now, and I expect that I will have it for quite a few more.

photo credit: Michal Zacharzewski, SXC.

Published or updated October 12, 2008.
Print or e-mail this article:

{ 6 comments… read them below or add one }

1 Mrs. Micah

I think I read about the flooded automobile fraud at the time. In that situation, new is definitely the best choice (or buying used in, like, Nebraska). 😉


2 Jeremie

I like to buy somewhat used automobiles. The ones that are 2-3 years old have dropped in price but still retain their main equity. As most people know, vehicles lose most of their “inflated value” (depreciation sucks) in the first three years. It also allows the first drivers to find out if there are any issues with the car before selling it. Until I start buying Lexus’s off the lot, I think I am cool with buying used.


3 Ryan

Mrs. Micah,
at the time, the flooded cars were being transported all over the US. It is actually easier to commit the fraud by transporting the cars out of state because then the thieves could get a clean title that didn’t have any reference to the car being totaled.

I would buy a used car now, but at the time, buying new was the best option for me. I agree, though… depreciation sucks!!! 😉

Ryan’s last blog post..I Bought a New Car, and Why it Was Good Idea For Me


4 Mrs. Micah

Good point. I think that might be what I heard. Since I wasn’t on the market for a car, I just ignored it.


5 Jim777

Don’t take this the wrong way… But there is never a case where buying a NEW car from a dealership is a good idea. NEVER.

Slightly Used is always a better deal.

Have you ever heard of eBay?? Have you ever seen the deals you can get on eBay buying slightly used cars??

Forget looking locally for a deal… Go to eBay and you’ll find amazing deals on cars in great condition that look brand new. You’ll pay THOUSANDS less than at any dealership. Dealerships simply know too much about the value of their cars to ever let you get a deal. They will make you THINK your getting a deal, but trust me, your not getting the deal they make you fell your getting.


6 Ryan

Jim, I understand your comment, but based on my situation, I felt it was the best option at the time. The used car market where I was (and in the surrounding states) was flooded with damaged cars from Hurricane Katrina (no pun intended).

I have heard of eBay and used it for some purchases, but I’m not comfortable buying a used car sight unseen. I could have bought a used car locally, but I lived in a small town that didn’t offer many options for my preferred vehicle. The nearest major city was a 2 hour drive, making it difficult to bid on a car on eBay or do a realistic use car search.

I paid more, but I also got peace of mind.


Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: