Save Time and Money by Trading in Your Car

by Ryan Guina

How do you get the best deal for your old car when you buy another car? Most people will tell you the best deal is to sell your old car on your own instead of trading it in to the dealership. I disagree. I think most people can save time and money by trading their car in – if they are able to get a fair price for their car.

Tax benefits of trading in your car

Why? Because there are tax benefits to trading in your old car. In most states, when you trade-in your car when purchasing another vehicle, you are only required to pay sales tax on the difference between the trade-in value and the price of the new car.

vintage-car.jpgLet’s look at an example that explains why I believe it can be better to trade in your car:

Without Trade-in:

  • New car purchase price: $30,000
  • Taxes paid (7% of $30,000): $2,100
  • Used car sold by owner: $16,000
  • Total cost of new car: $32,100 – $16,000 = $16,100

With Trade-in: (Remember, in this example, the price of the trade-in is deducted from the price of the new car for tax purposes).

  • New car purchase price – $30,000
  • Trade-in Value: $15,000
  • Taxes Paid (7% of $15,000): $1,050
  • Total cost of new car: $31,050 – 15,000 = $16,050

I admit, these numbers work perfectly, but you will find that even with lower numbers, the final result is very close. For example, when you buy a $25,000 car and have the option of selling your car yourself for $11,000 or trading it in for $10,000, selling the car on your own results in an extra $300 after tax benefits are considered. That $300 represents real money in your pocket; but I still think trading your car in can be a better deal. Here is why:

Trading in your car can save you time and money. When you trade-in your car, the deal happens that day. You do not have to place advertisements, locate a buyer, arrange test drives, wait for the buyer to line up financing, or deal with any other issues, including future liability. At the dealership you sign a few papers, and the car is no longer your responsibility.

When you sell the car yourself, there are no guarantees. You are responsible for listing the car for sale (which can cost money), finding a buyer, arranging a test drive, dealing with the buyer’s financing, determining a safe and secure method of payment, and handling other paperwork. Did I mention that it may take you several weeks to do everything?

In addition to the hassles of listing the car and finding a buyer, in some states the seller can be held liable for problems that occur shortly after the sale. Trading your car in negates those legal liabilities.

Is trading in your car always better? No. Sometimes the dealership will not give you a fair offer, and sometimes you can sell your car quickly and easily to a family member, friend, or coworker and not have to worry about the issues listed above. The tax benefits are also less substantial in states with low sales tax.

But, trading in your car is all about convenience. In the second example above, the net difference was only $300 savings for selling the car yourself. When you add up the time and costs involved, that extra $300 may not be worth the hassle.

The last time I bought a new car, I traded my old car in. I estimate I could have made an additional $1,000 on the sale price vs. trade-in price, but after the tax considerations, the total difference would have been in the ballpark of $500. I had other reasons to trade-in as well – I lived in a small town at the time, and actually drove several hours to a large city where I saved well over $1,000 on the price of my new car. That savings more than made up for the difference of trading my old car in.

The next time you buy a car, investigate how much you can get by selling your car or trading it in. You might just find out that trading your old car in is actually the best deal.

photo credit: magstefan.

Published or updated August 26, 2016.
Print or e-mail this article:

{ 8 comments… read them below or add one }

1 Eric

We had to fight the dealership to get what we felt was a fair deal on our trade-in. I do believe we could have gotten more if we sold it on our own, but it was easier just to get it taken care of at the dealership.

Good point about the tax implications. I hadn’t thought about that. Probably best we did trade it in.


2 Ryan

Eric, I agree, it can be a battle to get fair value on your trade-in, but if you can get good value, then the tax implications and less hassle make it well worth your while.

A lot of people don’t know about it, but the Kelley Blue Book also has a companion, the Black Book, that only dealers have access to. One of my friends who worked at a dealership let me know exactly what I should ask for my trade-in. The dealership I trade my car in didn’t want to give me that much, but finally decided to do it.

I’ll write about the purchase in an upcoming article.


3 Chief Family Officer

Thanks, Ryan! You make an excellent point that I hadn’t even considered – it makes it that much easier for me to go with the trade-in and not feel bad for not wanting to deal with the hassle of a private sale 😀


4 Ryan


I think too many people focus on the final trade-in/sale price of their old car vs. the effective value they receive.

I would still do an analysis for each situation, but you may find that the effective value you receive after tax considerations just make it easier to trade the old car in.


5 Sandee

Great post. I never realized that you only pay taxes on the difference between the new car and the trade in. Besides the Black Book, there is also another book that many dealers use called the NADA (National Automobile Dealers Association).

Sometimes, depending on the situation it makes sense for a person to donate their car instead of selling it or even trading it in. Some charities allow you to write off the full market value of your car on your taxes when you donate it. It won’t get you cash in your pocket up front but it might be a good option to consider if you think you will end up having to pay when tax time rolls around…


6 Ryan

Thanks for sharing these tips, Sandee!


7 Brooke

How would this work out if the trade in value was higher than the price of the vehicle you are purchasing? We are considering trading in our current vehicle, which dealers have offered us $17500 for, on a vehicle that costs about $14000. Thanks for the article and any info you have to offer!


8 Ryan Guina

Brooke, you should receive a check from the dealership for the difference in value. Keep in mind the dealer will likely quote additional expenses on the cost of the $14,000 vehicle, including things like documentation, dealership fees, registration, etc. But the sales tax may be canceled out. You can also try to negotiate the price of the $14,000 vehicle, and maybe get it for less. Try calling the dealership and asking them exactly how the process would work and what you might expect. If you are concerned about asking the dealership where you will be making the deal, then you can try asking a car salesman (if you know one personally) or you can call another dealership and mention you are considering trading in a high value vehicle for a lower cost vehicle and you want to know how the process works. Hopefully they will be able to tell you what to expect. I hope this helps!


Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: