Hard Credit Check vs. Soft Credit Check

by Patrick on August 8, 2008

Your credit score is an extremely important number. It can have an effect on your ability to get a loan, how much interest you will pay, your ability to rent a house or an apartment, or even get a job. But did you know that the simple act of having your credit score pulled too often can have a negative impact on your credit score? Too many hard credit pulls can be seen as a sign by lenders that you may be borrowing too much money and are at risk for not being able to pay back your loans.

A credit pull (also known as a credit check or credit inquiry) is when you or someone else accesses your credit history. But not all credit inquiries have the same effect on your credit score. There are times when pulling your score has no affect on your credit score. Why the difference? It depends on why the credit inquiry is made. There are two types of credit pulls, hard credit pulls and soft credit pulls.

Soft credit check vs. hard credit check

A soft credit check is one that does not affect your credit score. A soft credit check is recorded in your credit history, but is only visible to you and not visible to lenders. You can check your credit report and score as often as you want with no negative effects to your credit score. Some examples of soft credit inquiries are:

  • Credit score and credit reports you request for yourself.
  • Pre-approval credit checks done by credit card companies and mortgage lenders. (You know that junk mail you hate to receive? Lenders who send out pre-approved loan applications do a soft credit check to find potential customers in a certain credit score range. If you apply, then a hard credit check is made to verify your score).
  • Routine credit checks by your credit card or insurance company to review your current credit situation.
  • Pre-employment screenings by potential employers or for a security clearance.
  • Identity verification when opening a new bank account (note: some institutions do a hard credit inquiry).

A hard credit check is one that can negatively impact your credit score. These occur when you give a lender permission to check your credit history with the intent to open up a new line of credit. Each hard credit check can cause your score to drop by roughly 5 points and can effect your score for 6 months to a year. The hard credit pull is visible to anyone and will remain on your credit report for up to two years. The good news is that hard credit pulls are almost always voluntary – i.e. you are applying for a new line of credit and give permission for the credit inquiry to happen.

The reason your credit score will drop is because the more money you have access to through loans, the more difficult it is to repay. That is why your available credit is part of your credit score.

Some examples of hard credit pulls occur when:

  • You apply for a credit card.
  • You apply for a mortgage, auto loan, HELOC, or other loan.
  • Opening a new bank account at certain institutions. (here is a list of banks that do hard credit pulls).
  • Opening a new cell phone account.

Be careful when checking your credit score or applying for credit

Because too many hard credit pulls can lower your credit score, you should only get a hard credit pull when necessary. For example, when shopping for a car or looking for a house, don’t let every loan officer pull your credit score to tell you how much your payments will be. It is best to pull your own credit score (which counts as a soft credit pull) and ask them to run a preliminary check with your numbers. The loan officer should be able to give you an unofficial number based on your score and you can have them run the official numbers if you decide to take a loan out through them. Just be careful and don’t let them pull a bait and switch on you!

Related Articles:


Share This Article: | | Submit to PFBuzz.com | | Submit to Delicious | Submit to Reddit | Submit to Digg

Print or e-mail this article: Print This Post Print This Post | Email This Post Email This Post

{ 15 comments… read them below or add one }

1 NatalieMac August 8, 2008 at 5:56 pm

One important point – the method used to calculate your credit score takes into account the fact that you may need to shop around for the best rate, and hard credit pulls for the same type of account all made within a short amount of time have the same impact on your credit score as one hard credit pull.

For example, if you’re shopping for a car loan, it’s okay to let the dealer and a few different banks make a hard credit pull for a car loan within a period of two to four weeks. So feel safe shopping around for the best rate on a loan, mortgage or credit card. Just as long as you don’t draw out the process too much.

Reply

2 Patrick August 8, 2008 at 6:06 pm

Start-Up,

To be honest, I don’t know if you can reopen a line of credit after closing it and have it be seamless on your credit history. I recommend contacting your former credit card company and asking them if you can reopen the account and whether or not the card will be recognized with it’s original opening date. (I’m sure it will for the credit card company, but I don’t know if it will for your credit score). Sorry I can’t be of any more assistance.

NatalieMac,

Thanks for pointing that out!

Reply

3 Start-Up August 8, 2008 at 5:14 pm

Great post.

I have a question about credit pulls. Before I got into really paying attention to my credit score I closed a credit card account that I had used for a long time. I will be closing on my mortgage in the next two months and still have to lock down my interest rate. I think having that long standing credit card account would have helped my credit/FICO score. Any thoughts on whether I should try to get my account back up? Will my credit history for that account be returned if I re-open? Will it take a hard pull to do this even if I was in good standing when I closed it?

Reply

4 Patrick August 11, 2008 at 3:50 pm

Yes, the pre-approved credit applications are usually sent because someone has done a soft credit pull on you. It doesn’t affect your credit though. Why is it legal? Probably because large credit companies spent a lot of money and lobbied Congress to make it so.

Reply

5 KidsCraftZone August 11, 2008 at 3:46 pm

You mean to tell me every time I get that junk mail from my mortgage company and credit card lenders they are pulling my credit. I know you say it is not as bad as hard credit check but why are they allowed to do it at all? I guess I never realized how many things could negatively effect your credit. Great posting!

Reply

6 Laura August 21, 2008 at 3:36 pm

Is it legal or is there a limit to how many times a single company can do a credit check on a single person?

Reply

7 Patrick August 21, 2008 at 3:45 pm

Laura,

I’m not sure. If they are doing a soft credit check, it won’t affect your credit score, so it shouldn’t matter. Companies are only allowed to do a hard credit check if you give them permission.

Reply

8 Sheryl Massey September 19, 2008 at 3:52 pm

I applied for a car a month and a half ago and they are still checking my credit. They keep calling me and leaving messages for me to call them. I have spoken with them twice and told them I no longer interest but they continue to call me and run my credit. What can I do?

Reply

9 Patrick September 19, 2008 at 10:03 pm

Sheryl,

They should only run your credit once, and that is only with your permission. If they continue to contact you after you have repeatedly asked them not to, that can be considered harassment. I recommend asking to speak to a manager and explicitly request to be permanently removed fro their calling list. After that, they can no longer call you. As for credit checks, if they pulled your credit without permission, you may be able to have that removed from your credit report by contacting the credit bureaus and notifying them of an error. Good luck, and I hope the company stops harassing you.

Reply

10 Angel Guzman June 3, 2009 at 9:28 am

I have been chashing the requirements for a refi @ first 580 was needed when I got to the 580 the requirement went up to 600 now it is 620. Last week i had a 607 mid score but when i applied for an approval online they returned my mid score of 589 that’s 18 points. The loan officers all stated that when they pulled an inquiry it does not effect the score. In the past 2 months I have been trying to get the best deal to refi. Is there any way to increase the score 30 points I need to do this refi within the month. Thanks

Reply

11 Patrick June 3, 2009 at 9:33 am

Improving your score takes time, and I don’t know if it can be done in a month. Here are some tips on how to improve your credit score.

Reply

12 Jen November 19, 2009 at 11:15 am

I was looking into an alarm system and had the sales person out to my house. Went over some numbers with him. I signed the contract but was never told that my credit was going to be pulled. Is that legal?

Reply

13 Patrick November 19, 2009 at 11:27 am

Credit checks are common, but the company pulling your credit file needs to have a valid reason and usually, if not always, your permission. Was it written in the contract that your credit would be checked, or mentioned verbally?

Reply

14 Jen November 19, 2009 at 11:32 am

No it was not mentioned or read in the contract.

Reply

15 Patrick November 19, 2009 at 11:40 am

To be honest, I’m not sure what your options are. You can complain to the company, Better business Bureau, or state attorney generals office, though I’m not sure what, if anything will come of it. State laws probably vary on this topic, so I’m not sure I can offer much more than that. Sorry!

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post:

.